SWITCH Security-Blog

SWITCH-CERT IT-Security Blog


6 Comments

Optimizing Negative Caching Time in DNS

A recent presentation by SIDN (.nl) at the Spring 2016 DNS-OARC workshop reminded me of the importance of Time-To-Live (TTL) values in TLD zones. Specifically, it got me thinking about lowering the negative caching time in .ch/.li from currently 1 hour to 15 minutes.

What is negative caching?
When a resolver receives a response to a query, it caches it for the duration of the TTL specified by the record. For positive responses, the record contains the TTL, but for negative responses (response code NXDOMAIN), there is no answer to the query question. For this case, the response contains the SOA record of the zone in the authority section. Negative caching is specified in RFC 2308 as the minimum of the SOA record’s TTL and the SOA minimum field. For example, the original SOA record of the .ch zone looked as follows:

dig +nocmd +noall +answer @a.nic.ch ch. soa
ch. 3600 IN SOA a.nic.ch. helpdesk.nic.ch. 2016041421 900 600 1123200 3600

The SOA TTL is 3600, and the SOA minimum time is also set to 3600. The minimum of these two values is of course 3600 too. That means the negative caching time for any .ch domain lookup is one hour.

A lower negative caching time is more user-friendly
People who are about to register a new domain name may also look up the name over DNS. However, this means that they just cached the non-existence of the name in the resolver they are using. A domain can be registered in a matter of minutes, and this can prevent them from using the domain name on their network for the duration of the negative caching time.
Continue reading